Brief Review of 「假如美夢能成真」 (Spoiler)

作者：首領八奇│假如美夢能成真│2011-09-10 18:14:24│巴幣：0│人氣：693

This is a bilingual version of book review. So if you can't read English, don't worry, you can find Chinese comments in the bottom. : )

本書評為中英雙語，若您不會看英文卻也想大概了解本書，請往下看即可。 >w<

評論會有劇情雷喔。

圖片版權為東立出版社所有。

The book contains five different yuri stories. All other four episodes are quite short ones.

The first and also the most important episode is called "假如美夢能成真". A story of complicated love between three girls: "小陽" "小海" and "月子". 月子 likes 小陽 as 小海 likes 月子. Too difficult to understand? Just like this chain:

小海→月子→小陽

Despite she didn't really like 小海, 月子 still accept her for some unknown reasons. But in the end 小海 found out the truth, she was not the one 月子 truly loved (and she understood it on the bed, the worst case scenario). However there was no Nice Boat ending, in fact she didn't even get mad at 月子. After few silence seconds, she said:

" You (月子) can use my body as a replacement of 小陽."

What ending is waiting for them in the future?

Comment:

A touching story. I have to admit that when I saw 小海 said about replacement with a forcing smile, my heart almost broke up. What a poor girl......

Although there was a sorrow beginning, the story ends happily. So readers who don't like sad ending (like me) should not worry about it, just watch it and see how it developing.

The four episodes left are not that impressive.

"美麗的女生" : About a girl fell in love with a girl in basketball club.

"情書" : A introvert girl who wrote a story and the characters were based on the girl she loved in reality.

"一身黑裝的女孩": The love between a little girl (called loli in ACG) and a young lady. But this little girl was a cat actually...

"雨和初戀" : About two friends who grew up together since childhood.

All four stories are too short. When you finally started to enjoy the plot and then oops, it was over, you couldn't even remember the character yet. That was the biggest problem.

Here is my conclusion: It's not a yuri masterpiece, not even that fascinating compares with other yuri comics I read in that time. But still, it's a regular-standard level yuri comics.

I'm gonna give it... 70 points.

本書是由五篇故事組成的，而除了第一篇之外，其他四篇都是短篇小故事。

第一篇也是最重要的一篇

「假如美夢能成真」

是敘述三個女孩子小海、月子、小陽之間複雜的愛戀關係。小海喜歡月子，但是月子真正喜歡的是小陽。簡單的圖示表就是

小海→月子→小陽

雖然月子真正喜歡的是小陽，但她還是接受了小海的告白，我也不是很清楚為什麼，似乎是想彌補自己追不到小陽的遺憾。然而小海終究還是知道了月子真正的心意(在床上時知道的，有夠慘)，可是她並沒有上演好船結局，反而淡淡的說了句

「沒關係的...妳可以把我的身體...當成小陽的替代品。」

這篇故事挺感人的，尤其是小海勉強笑著說出當成替代品那段更是令人心碎。不過雖然如此，整個故事最後是快樂結局喔。不喜歡悲劇的讀者也可以放心！享受故事就對了。

其他的故事就沒那麼讓人印象深刻了。

"美麗的女生" : 一個女生喜歡上籃球社的女社員，看完感覺一個是S一個是M。

"情書" : 內向的眼鏡女孩已自己喜歡的女生當作範本寫小說，把自己內心的情感化為文字，然而有一天卻被喜歡的女生看到了......